Apr 202011
 

Jessica LostOne of the things I related to most in Jessica Lost was the chapter describing how Bunny behaved when she became an everyday parent after relinquishment. I’ve talked about post-placement parenting before, both in how it changed me and how I encounter difficult scenarios that not everyone does. To hear Bunny talk about it, though we came from different generations, made me feel normal, something I don’t always get to feel when it comes to the topic of parenting or adoption.

I never told my children about The Baby. When they were little, I thought they’d think I might give them away, too.

But later there was never a right time, never a moment in which I could say that I’d given away my first child.

There are obvious differences between my experience and Bunny’s in that quote. My children know and have always known. On the night that my first son was born, I sat in the rocking chair with him by the window, looking out on the hospital lawn at all of the Christmas lights. My husband was taking a shower as I rocked and told my firstborn son about his sister — my firstborn. There has never been a time when they didn’t know her name, didn’t know about her.

But I still harbor that fear that they will have their own fears about family permanency. BigBrother has been hinting around some of his fears as he begins to ask more questions and talk more freely about adoption and its process. I work on reassuring them that they aren’t going anywhere without using language that would be scary in itself. I’ve never verbalized, “I’ll never give you away,” because, knowing my oldest, he would think, “Why did she just say that? Does that mean she could or would?” And we’d be on a cycle of questions for four days straight. I try to talk about families being forever and how we love each other no matter what. But BigBrother’s question is coming soon. I hope I’m ready.

The birth of The Baby, and her loss, certainly affected the kind of mother I became: over-protective, full of the fear, without identifying it, that I would lose another child, that the baby would be taken from me.

The difference here is that I do identify that fear. It shapes my every move, my every decision in parenting. I have learned and continue to learn how to parent around it or, really, how to parent with that fear. I was discussing this very thing with Dawn and Kate the other day, about how I’ve had to work so hard to land this helicopter and how there really are no resources for parenting with this fear. I’ll go along for a few weeks at a time and think I’m doing great; I’ll sit at the park while they play and read a book instead of hovering, hovering, hovering. But then BigBrother walks away from me for Kindergarten screening and I cry because I don’t know where he is or what he’s doing or who he’s with. I can’t stand the not knowing. And so I fall back into realizing that my parenting is forever shaped by that loss, that fear.

I was much less of a mother than the woman who adopted her, who was there for all those things, who picked her clothes up off the floor, and taught her to say “Please” and “Thank you” and who sang lullabies at night. I hoped she sang lullabies.

But if love counts — and it must, at least a little — then I am also her mother, because I loved her. I loved her for four days, and for forty-two years, and forever.

Yes, I blubbered all over myself at that point.

I remember in the early days of our open adoption when we were still floundering around our roles and our titles. Dee asked me if I would just rather be called “mother” instead of “birth mom” or “first mom” or any of that jazz. I balked. I straight up balked. I had been all but brainwashed by my non-agency to simply be the birth mom. I look back on that and wish I would have had the common sense to see what gift was being offered to me. But, to be honest, it doesn’t matter to me that I am now simply Jenna, her [Munchkin's] birth mom. I know who I am. I am secure in my role in her life. I have always loved her. I will always love her. And it counts.

It counts.


[Disclosure: I was provided a free copy of the book. My honest review can be found here.]

Apr 182011
 

Jessica LostJessica Lost: A Story of Birth, Adoption & The Meaning of Motherhood by Bunny Crumpacker and J.S. Picariello was a difficult book for me to read. It took longer than I expected because of life getting in the way and because the book reached out and smacked me more than a few times.

The book is written in alternating chapters — one by Bunny, the birth mother, followed with one by Jil, the adoptee. While I am a known alternating-chapter-dissenter, it worked so amazingly in this book. I think if either author had written their story on their own or if they had written in the format where Bunny told her whole story and then Jil told hers, the weight of the book would have been lost. The full concept of what adoption feels like would have been missed. Not because one cannot understand concepts like grief and loss if only told by a birth mother or if only told by an adoptee; no, we know from blogs that individuals convey those points quite well. But when you put them together, the loss of mother and child? It’s impossible not to be moved, to ask questions, to shed two or eighty tears.

I feel as if I can’t do the “plot” of this memoir justice. I suppose that’s what happens when you take two really good writers, an emotional topic and put it all together. It turns out to be this amazingly well-written piece of work that is difficult to explain; I feel like my words can’t adequately describe what the book is about… But, in short, we follow Bunny through her quick college-aged marriage, unexpected pregnancy during a rocky marriage, birth, divorce and search for her daughter as we simultaneously follow Jil through her tumultuous child-to-teen relationship with her adoptive mom, a series of devastating losses, the birth of her children and the eventual search for her mother.

Bunny’s story is her own, but there are shreds of recognition to the stories of other birth mothers and the birth mother experiences woven throughout her words. She blocked much of the pregnancy and birthing process. She held her shame close and thus kept the secret from most everyone in her life; her husband was the last person she told prior to reunion. The relinquishment of her daughter affected how she parented her children later in life. I found myself nodding — and crying — so frequently as I read through her chapters.

Jil’s story is her own as well, but having read adoptee blogs for so many years, I see some other sameness represented in her struggles growing up, the inner dialogue about whether contact would be good or not and other bits and pieces. Her story broke my heart several times and her chapter on loss was almost too much for me to take — and I didn’t even live through it. As she struggles to understand what makes us who we are — nature or nurture — I found myself asking the same questions. I wonder that of the Munchkin and the how’s and who’s of the girl she is becoming and the woman she will become.

There were many quotes throughout the book that struck me on the deepest of levels. I will be hitting on a few over the next few days; one on naming, one on parenting post-placement, one on knowing who you are and one on adoption vs. abortion vs. society’s view on the two. While Bunny’s pregnancy and relinquishment of Jil happen in 1954, a different era of societal thought adoption and how it was carried out, many of the things that Bunny and Jil shared are truths even today. We like to believe that society has changed vastly and that we’re helping adoptees, birth parents and adoptive parents better maneuver the tricky currents of post-placement. But some things are still true, decades later.

Jessica Lost is really a must read for all sides of the triad with the caveat that it is a hard read at times. Adoption is not all butterflies and roses; it is loss, it is hurt, it is confusion, it is secrets hidden from ourselves, others and society. Being able to recognize that we all have our own unique stories but that there are still some aspects of adoption that tie us all together is also important going into this book. This story is not your story or your mother’s story or your child’s story; this is the story of Bunny, Jil and those in their lives. But this story may help you understand things you maybe never thought to think about, whether related to your own experience or that of someone else in your life.

This is the fifth book I have read for the Adoption Reading Challenge (I took a break for a month).

I will be interviewing Jil for BlogHer sometime before the book is officially released on May 3. I will let you know when that is live. Until then, feel free to pre-order the book. You won’t regret it.


[Disclosures: I received a free copy of this book for review. Links above are through Amazon Affiliates.]