Aug 162010
 

He asked me if I thought he’d be a good father.

I have been asked loaded questions in my day, but none quite so heavy.

It is not that I think he should avoid parenthood because he is a birth father. I am not dooming him to a life of childlessness because of everything that happened. I was just as big a part in the decision to relinquish as he was… or, if I’m honest, I was a bigger part of that decision. He signed the papers, yes, but I was the driving force. And I am an amazing mom to my two boys. I would have fought — tooth and nail — anyone who tried to tell me that the relinquishment of my firstborn made it impossible for me to be a good mother to any subsequent children. I’d still fight tooth and nail.

But still, the question hit me hard.

He never asked me that question when I was pregnant with the Munchkin. Granted, I started in with the adoption plan shortly after my 18th week of pregnancy once I had been placed on bed rest after my kidney surgery. Perhaps he never had a chance to get to that question. Maybe I switched gears to adoption speak before he even had a chance to grasp that he had helped create a life and was, in some way, responsible for the outcome. I don’t know why he never asked me that question.

I don’t know why he has chosen to ask me now, even before he and his wife have conceived a child.

But it hurt me in a place that I didn’t know still bore scars. My immediate reaction was deep and visceral and full of anger and fury and rage. If I was a throwing person, I would have thrown something, breaking it simply for the release. To see the shards of glass as a visual representation of how I once felt and how I suddenly felt all over again. Thankfully, I chose not to say anything for a few days. I recognized my anger as something deeper within myself, tied to my guilt and shame and sense of utter failure. I quieted up for most of the week, unable and unwilling to discuss what I was feeling with anyone.

He has apologized for everything that happened back then. I have forgiven him. But I tiptoe around real discussion with him during our infrequent bouts of contact. I discuss my career, what the boys are doing, the constant desire for a vacation and a nap and other such simplistic bits of conversation. When I was pregnant with my first son, I couldn’t have imagined asking him, “Do you think I’ll make a good mother?” Then again, I hadn’t forgiven him at that point, so maybe that makes all the difference. I suppose I am most taken aback by how easily he asked me such a loaded question, as if he didn’t even recognize how it might pierce the deepest, darkest parts of my soul that I keep hidden from almost everyone at all times.

The truth is that most people who ask the question — will I be a good parent — are usually those who will be fine. Questioning one’s ability and gauging readiness is important. It’s not a guarantee, but it’s a sign that good things are happening in the head and the heart. I have no reason to believe that he wouldn’t be a good father.

I just wish he would have asked that question seven years and one month ago.

Jun 212009
 

First and foremost, Happy Father’s Day.

We’ve been asked to write about the fathers involved in our open adoptions for this second round of the Open Adoption Roundtable. It’s a kind of complicated segment of our open adoption. When I first considered what to write about, I thought of Munchkin’s biological and adoptive fathers. And then I realized that our story is shaped by so many other fathers.

I loved my daughter’s birth father once upon a memory. For giving me the most beautiful girl known to mankind, I will always love him. We weren’t a match. Our personalities were similar though we liked very different things. He’s a numbers and math and money type of man while I’m a music and words and not-money type of woman. Despite those differences, we were both intensely passionate. We were both extremely stubborn. When we wanted something, nothing stood in our way. At one point in time, that want was for each other. Things changed as we changed. We grew apart. We moved on. Timing of life threw us back together and a baby was conceived, carried and born. He wasn’t around during the second and third half of that process. I was angry for a very long time but I forgave him even before he apologized. I had to. Every time I looked in her eyes, he was there. Every time she laughed, I heard him. I couldn’t find it in me to be angry. Even though she wasn’t with me, without him, she wouldn’t have been there at all.

I first clicked with J, Munchkin’s adoptive dad, more than D. Women, by nature, are more stand-offish at first. Men, however, have nothing to lose. He was positive, encouraging and easy to talk to. Over the years, D and I became close and it wasn’t necessary to filter conversation through him. However, I still loved his ability to lighten the mood when necessary. And, in open adoption, it is sometimes necessary. Things can get heavy from time to time. Laughter is good. I am glad that my daughter has that reminder in his life, to laugh and not take everything so seriously. It’s an important lesson.

I have a memory of my father from our time in the hospital with the Munchkin. He is sitting next to me, to the left of my hospital bed. He is holding Munchkin’s head in his hands, her body stretched along the length of his forearm. She is small; he is so big. His eyes scrunch like they do when he is trying not to break down into tears. I want to look away. I want him to have his moment, to be alone with it. But I can’t look away. I stare and let it be permanently branded into my heart, my soul, my being. My father with my daughter. My father with his first grandchild, unknown at that time she could be his only granddaughter. (My brother still possesses this possibility.) The memory is with me to this day. My father is a strong, wonderful man who loves with his whole being. I learned a lot about him that day, in that moment.

My husband loved the Munchkin before she was born. For those who don’t know our story, we started dating after the Munchkin was conceived. He wanted to be there, to love her. Life got in the way when my kidney threw a wrench in the works. I was instructed to make my decision as if he didn’t exist. I hurt him by doing that; I saw the tears and held him as he cried when I came home from the hospital without her. He doesn’t cry like the men in my family, but he did that night. I wonder, at times, if I’ll ever forgive myself. But then, oh then, I remember him on that first visit, lifting her into the air. I remember him holding me in our hotel room. I remember him encouraging me, that first Mother’s Day. He’s always been my biggest cheerleader. He’s always been my biggest fan. He’s always been the best father I have known, even before he had boys of his own to chase around the living room and toss into the air, laughter filling the room and my heart. I don’t know how I lucked out and found him. I don’t know why he puts up with me in the summer when I’m too hot and, as such, too cranky. But he does.

And, now, we have M added to the equation. He’s quiet. Even more than my husband. But I’ve seen him with Munchkin and JD. Moreover, I’ve seen him with Munchkin, JD, BigBrother and LittleBrother. He can handle it. I felt fine when he was watching them all. It’s been a weird mental adjustment, of course. I didn’t choose M to be in my daughter’s life. He wasn’t on that profile. There was no way to know he would be someone I would have close contact with as I was planning to place my daughter for adoption. But he’s adjusted well to the idea of open adoption, spending a very crazy weekend at my house. He’s someone I can tell that loves my daughter, loves her brother and loves their mother. I can’t imagine someone else I’d rather have in her life in this regard. While it isn’t necessary for them to move forward with their life together, I give my full blessing to D and M. I hope that they find the happiness that I know my husband and I have found in one another, in our life together.

I think she’s lucky, that Munchkin, for having so many fathers in her story. A biological father who gave her a strength she won’t fully understand until she begins fighting battles on her own. An adoptive dad who gives her humor and the reminder that laughter is good. A “bonus dad” in my husband, who loves her more than any of us can understand. A biological grandfather who, if things had gone differently, would have taught her to throw a ball just as he taught me. And a stepdad-to-be who was thrown into the crazy world of open adoption and didn’t bat an eyelash. Yes, she’s lucky. So very lucky.